Covering a popcorn ceiling in Modesto, CA
You do not have to scrape a ceiling to stop looking at it. Covering leaves the old texture where it is and puts a new surface underneath it.
What covering means
The Consumer Product Safety Commission describes two kinds of repair for material that may contain asbestos. Sealing treats the material with a sealant. Covering places something over or around it. Both leave the material in place, which is the point.
For a ceiling, covering usually means a new layer fastened below the old one. Ask each installer exactly what they would put up and how they would attach it.
The catch: covering only keeps the old texture undisturbed if the installer does not sand, scrape or drill it along the way. If the ceiling has not been tested, ask how they plan to fasten the new layer, and get a test first if the answer involves disturbing the texture.
Source: CPSC, Asbestos in the Home.
Covering or removing?
| Cover | Remove | |
|---|---|---|
| Old texture | Stays in place, hidden. | Gone. |
| If it contains asbestos | It is still there, so future work on that ceiling has to account for it. | Removal is asbestos work for a Cal/OSHA-registered contractor. |
| Ceiling height | Drops by the thickness of the new layer. | Unchanged. |
| Good to know | Tell future buyers and contractors what is under the new surface. | Keep the lab report. |
This option is good if the existing drywall/plaster is in a reasonable condition and the improvement required is just smoothing out the surface. If the ceiling is warped, damaged or has water stains, adding new drywall/boards will mean that the problem remains hidden.
Common questions
Do I still need a test if I am only covering?
If the installer will disturb the texture in any way, yes. If nothing is sanded, scraped or drilled, a test still tells you what you are sealing in. See asbestos testing.
Is painting over the texture the same as sealing it?
CPSC describes sealing as treating the material with a sealant that binds or coats the fibers. Whether a given paint does that is a question for a professional, not something this site can confirm.
Can a covered ceiling be removed later?
Yes, but the same rules apply then. If the old texture contains asbestos, removing it later is asbestos work.
Is leaving it alone really an option?
Yes. CPSC says material in good condition that will not be disturbed should be left alone.
Which option do installers here offer?
That varies by installer. Say in your request that you are considering covering, and ask the removal questions too so you can compare.
Ask a local installer
Send the rooms, the year the home was built and your test result, and an independent installer can follow up.